Unreal Jumperz

Floater · Clan Leader Joined: 12 Jan 2008 Posts: 261

Here I'll make reviews of the new jump maps...
Lets start with jm_pipeline which i just tested....
1st some good points:
the map has easy and hard version
the idea of sewer is not bad Wink

some nice jumps but not much
kind of nice atmosphere ... only kind of...
Now what i didnt like:
Horrible texturing! Most of the textures arent sized to the objects and look awful..
water textures are placed over other textures on some places
because of the unscaled textures u cant see clearly how far are the jumps
no end sign.. i didnt even understand that i had finished in the 1st moment...
NO scripting or effects!
map is very small... needs more jumps
too dark at some places
too dark in the reflections room... If i didnt know about the reflections in the mud i wouldnt have spotted it lol
way is not clear at many places.. ai could at least put some arrows

But as you know 1st opinion is always wrong so i may like the map later Smile

overall: Not bad as a 1st map by ai but there are many things to be fixed... I give it 2/5
_________________
xfire: shif7

Kjx · Clan Leader Joined: 12 Jan 2008 Posts: 386

i dont agree with you in some points, i saw no places where it is 2 dark and the way is very clear Smile

and the map is small yes, but the jumps are hard so that will compensate it

Kryptonic · Posted: Thu Jan 24, 2008 6:00 pm Post subject:

I also don't agree with you floater.
I like the map very much and I didn't see any too dark places.
Also I didn't see any bad textures, but I've no idea of mapping Wink

And I always knew where to jump, so for me the way was clear.
_________________
Xfire : crush169 Smile

Kjx · Clan Leader Joined: 12 Jan 2008 Posts: 386

its offtopic but: wouldnt it be an idea to post all the ratings u made of the jumpmaps float?

Floater · Clan Leader Joined: 12 Jan 2008 Posts: 261

ill post em but first i wanna change some of them... Wink

_________________
xfire: shif7

Cheesy · Posted: Sat Jan 26, 2008 4:38 pm Post subject:

Ok i have to agree with floater it was to dark for me in the big room so i put it brighter and.....the texturing at the beginning......never mentioned!
But i have to say that the way was pretty clear and that he had some really nice ideas for some jumps.
But it is to short even if you say its hard which makes it long,thats true yes,but! thats not a real lenght! It just takes you longer to do a jump which means that the time you need is just longer not the map Wink

!
Though i got to say i really liked the map but as an objective ranking i would say 3/5
_________________
Vote yes for Obama!

Kjx · Clan Leader Joined: 12 Jan 2008 Posts: 386

i want to see the others ratings made by float to compare it Very Happy

Kryptonic · Posted: Sat Jan 26, 2008 9:10 pm Post subject:

I'd give 4,5/5 cause its a great map but too short
_________________
Xfire : crush169 Smile

Kjx · Clan Leader Joined: 12 Jan 2008 Posts: 386

a 5 star map has no bad point and u call a bad point so xD

i would give 3,5 for it Wink

Floater · Clan Leader Joined: 12 Jan 2008 Posts: 261

so we have 2, 3, 3.5 , 4.5
so far it is overall 3.25
Very Happy

not a bad score....
_________________
xfire: shif7

Kjx · Clan Leader Joined: 12 Jan 2008 Posts: 386

Cheesy · Posted: Sun Jan 27, 2008 6:27 pm Post subject:

LOL thought about it again and as i had a look at this topic again i have to say
that the result of my thoughts were the same as kjx�s opinion is:3.5 points for ar carambas first map! Wink

_________________
Vote yes for Obama!